There’s something magical about historical fiction that transports you completely into another time and place, making you forget about the modern world around you. Lisa See’s “Lady Tan’s Circle of Women” did exactly that for me, whisking me away to 15th century Ming Dynasty China with such vivid detail that I could almost smell the medicinal herbs and hear the rustle of silk robes.
The story follows Tan Yunxian, a young girl from a privileged family who finds herself drawn into the world of traditional Chinese medicine through her grandmother’s teachings. What struck me immediately was how See managed to paint such a rich portrait of women’s lives during this period without getting bogged down in historical exposition. The details about foot binding, while difficult to read (I actually had to put the book down several times during these scenes), were handled with sensitivity while still conveying the brutal reality of the practice.
Being Asian myself, I found myself particularly moved by how See portrayed the complex dynamics between women of different social classes. The friendship between Yunxian and Meiling, a girl training to be a midwife, resonated deeply with me. It reminded me of conversations with my own grandmother about the strict social hierarchies that existed in her youth, though thankfully not nearly as rigid as in Ming Dynasty China!
The medical aspects of the story were absolutely fascinating. As someone who grew up with a mother who swore by traditional Chinese medicine for everything from common colds to chronic pain, I was completely absorbed by the detailed descriptions of various treatments and remedies. See’s research shines through in these sections without ever feeling like a textbook. I found myself taking notes about some of the herbal combinations mentioned, though I probably shouldn’t admit that publicly!
What really sets this book apart is how See explores the various ways women wielded power within the confines of their restricted lives. While reading about Yunxian’s struggle to practice medicine despite societal constraints, I couldn’t help but think about my own mother’s stories of fighting to pursue her education against traditional expectations. The parallel, though separated by centuries, felt striking.
The writing is simply gorgeous. See has this incredible ability to make even the smallest details feel significant. Her descriptions of the various residences, particularly “The Garden of Fragrant Delights,” are so vivid that I found myself sketching little drawings in my reading journal. Each location feels like its own character, contributing to the atmospheric quality of the novel.
One of the most compelling aspects of the story is how See portrays the relationships between women. The “circle of women” referenced in the title isn’t just a clever phrase – it’s the beating heart of the novel. These relationships feel authentic and nuanced, showing both the support and complications that can exist in female friendships across social boundaries.
I particularly appreciated how See didn’t shy away from showing the contradictions in her characters. Yunxian, for instance, is progressive enough to fight for her right to practice medicine but still binds her own daughters’ feet. These complexities make the characters feel real rather than mere symbols of female empowerment.
The pacing is perfectly balanced between the intimate moments of daily life and the larger dramatic events that shape Yunxian’s journey. I read this book over a weekend, totally ignoring my usual Sunday dim sum plans with friends because I couldn’t bear to put it down. (They forgave me after I bought them bubble tea the following week!)
What makes this book even more remarkable is that it’s based on a real historical figure. Learning this in the acknowledgments gave me chills – knowing that Tan Yunxian’s medical writings still exist today adds another layer of significance to an already powerful story.
If you love historical fiction that combines meticulous research with compelling storytelling, this book is an absolute must-read. It’s perfect for book clubs too – I can already imagine the heated discussions about gender roles, social class, and tradition versus progress that this story would inspire.
Sets down teacup thoughtfully
This is the kind of book that stays with you long after you’ve turned the last page. Just last night, I found myself staring at my Chinese medicine cabinet, wondering about the generations of women who developed these healing traditions that we still benefit from today. See has created something truly special here – a window into history that feels incredibly relevant to our present moment.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get two free novels!
