I don’t typically read a lot of historical non-fiction, so I was a bit nervous diving into Oathbreakers: The War of Brothers That Shattered an Empire and Made Medieval Europe. My usual reading consists of cozy romances and young adult fantasies, but something about this dramatic family feud caught my attention! To be honest, my knowledge of Charlemagne before this book was basically limited to what I vaguely remembered from high school history class (which wasn’t much!).
A Surprisingly Engaging Writing Style
The writing style in Oathbreakers really surprised me! Instead of being dry and academic like I feared, Gabriele and Perry keep things light and conversational. Their chatty tone and sprinkled-in humor made the complex historical events much more digestible for a historical novice like myself. Though I have to say, sometimes the jokes felt a bit forced and pulled me out of the narrative. I appreciate them trying to make medieval history more accessible, but I found myself wishing they’d dial back the comedy just a tad.
Characters That Feel Real
The authors do an amazing job bringing these historical figures to life! Louis the Pious and his squabbling sons feel like real people with relatable motivations, not just names in a textbook. I loved getting inside their heads and understanding the personal drama behind the political maneuvering. The family dynamics totally sucked me in – it was like reading about a medieval reality TV show, but with actual kingdoms at stake!
Thoughtful Handling of Historical Sources
The way Gabriele and Perry handle historical sources is fascinating. They’re super upfront about when they’re speculating or filling in gaps in the records. I really appreciated their honesty about the challenges of piecing together events from biased and incomplete chronicles. It gave me a whole new appreciation for how historians actually do their work.
The Power of Oaths and Honor
Speaking of historical sources – I found the exploration of medieval oaths and honor absolutely riveting! Who knew promises were such a big deal back then? The authors do a fantastic job explaining how oath-breaking wasn’t just considered rude, but a serious moral and political crisis. It really helps explain why these family betrayals were such a huge deal.
Vivid Battle Scenes
The Battle of Fontenoy in 841 was described so vividly that I felt like I was right there watching this pivotal moment unfold. The authors manage to convey both the tactical details and emotional weight of brothers literally fighting brothers. It’s heartbreaking to think about how this one battle essentially destroyed what Charlemagne spent his life building.
A Few Navigation Challenges
I’ll admit, I did get a bit lost in all the political maneuvering sometimes. There are a lot of similar-sounding names (so many Louis-es!) and complex alliances to keep track of. I found myself flipping back to earlier chapters more than once to remind myself who was allied with whom. A family tree diagram would have been super helpful!
Modern Day Parallels
The authors make some really interesting connections to modern politics and family dynamics. While they never get too heavy-handed with the parallels, it’s fascinating to see how some patterns of human behavior really haven’t changed in over a thousand years. Power struggles between siblings, parents playing favorites, promises made and broken – it all feels surprisingly relevant.
Personal Stories That Shine
My favorite parts were definitely the more personal, human moments they managed to uncover from the historical record. Like the attempted coup by Pepin the Hunchback against his own father Charlemagne – there’s so much family drama and emotion packed into that one episode. These glimpses of personality and relationships really helped me connect with these long-dead historical figures.
I definitely recommend Oathbreakers to anyone curious about medieval history but intimidated by dense academic texts. While I occasionally wished for more in-depth analysis in certain areas, the accessible writing style and focus on human drama kept me thoroughly engaged. The authors strike a nice balance between scholarly reliability and entertaining storytelling.
That said, if you’re a serious history buff looking for really detailed analysis of primary sources or deep dives into medieval political theory, you might find this a bit light. But for someone like me, who usually sticks to fiction and was looking to dip their toes into medieval history, it was perfect! I actually find myself wanting to learn more about the Carolingian period now – which I never thought I’d say!
The book left me with a new appreciation for how fragile even the mightiest empires can be when family loyalty breaks down. It’s a reminder that behind all the grand historical events we read about, there are very human stories of love, betrayal, ambition, and loss. Oathbreakers brings those human elements to the forefront in a way that really resonated with me.
In conclusion, while this may not be my usual literary fare, I’m so glad I stepped out of my comfort zone with Oathbreakers. It’s made me realize that with the right authors as guides, even topics I thought would be too intimidating can become absolutely fascinating. Now excuse me while I go add more medieval history books to my ever-growing TBR pile!
Subscribe to our newsletter and get two free novels!
